Tastier Wines Using Fewer Pesticides

By Sondra Forsyth

Wine-making is steeped in age-old traditions, but to address the threat of pests and concerns over heavy pesticide use, vintners are turning to science. With the goal of designing better grape breeds, scientists are parsing the differences between wild American grapes — which make terrible wine but are pest-resistant — and the less hardy grape species pressed for fine wines worldwide. They reported their findings in July 2015 in the American Chemical Society’s Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry.

A release from the society explains that with every sip of their preferred drink, wine lovers from across the globe are appreciating the taste of a single species of grape, Vitis vinifera. Although it comes in many varieties, or cultivars, the species remains largely unevolved and susceptible to pests. With growing concern over the potential harm that pesticides might cause and the rise in fungicide resistance, some winemakers are developing hybrid grapes that are a cross between the hardy, wild American types — such as Vitis californica — and vinifera. But no one had done a direct comparison of the two to see which traits winemakers should borrow from each to make the best wine grape. Fulvio Mattivi and colleagues wanted to fill that gap.

The researchers found that compared to the high concentrations in the vinifera varieties in the study, the American grapes had low levels of metabolites such as procyanidins that are considered crucial to the body and healthfulness of fine wine. They were also missing several compounds common in vinifera grapes that lead to appealing aromatic notes. But the American species were high in polyphenolic compounds called stillbenoids that are anti-fungal.

The particular hybrids analyzed in the study, however, contained low amounts of procyanidins and other desirable compounds. The researchers conclude that this kind of chemical profiling will help inform future breeding studies to design a better grape.